"Evermore" just disappoints, as a (to my ears) pretty generic thud. I've heard the film vocals (perfectly nice) and the Groban cover. Neither adds much to the character or his moment, or the Mencken songboook. "If I Can't Love Her," cut because its swell of emotion signaled an act break, had high stakes and it soared. This song feels like any in any Disney animated version of anything. I was hoping for magic. If someone else hears it, great.