Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Washington, D.C.

Diner
Signature Theatre

Also see Susan's reviews of Famous Puppet Death Scenes and The Tempest


Adam Kantor, Josh Grisetti, Derek Klena, Matthew James Thomas, Aaron C. Finley, and Bryan Fenkart
Signature Theatre in Arlington, Virginia, is presenting the world premiere of Diner, a musical based on the 1982 movie about young men coping with imminent adulthood in 1959 Baltimore, and it's solidly entertaining if a bit rough around the edges. Barry Levinson, the movie's director and screenwriter, wrote the book for the musical, while Sheryl Crow (music and lyrics) has crafted a cohesive score with strong, era-appropriate elements of doo-wop, R&B, and rock-and-roll.

Diner is an ensemble piece, with six leading male roles and three main supporting women, and director-choreographer Kathleen Marshall has found a talented and well-matched ensemble. Derek Klena gives the flashiest performance as Boogie, a hotshot driven by hormones and his need to gamble on anything, but equally entertaining are Josh Grisetti as Shrevie, whose life revolves around his love of music trivia, and Matthew James Thomas as heavy-drinking Fenwick, aimless and living off a trust fund.

The action still centers on the bonding among the six male friends and their inability to comprehend the women in their lives, but Levinson has made the good decision to let the women's voices be heard more plainly here than in the movie. Specifically, the friends have gathered for the wedding of football fanatic Eddie (Adam Kantor) and Elyse (Tess Soltau); she barely appears in the movie but here she's a strong presence along with Shrevie's besieged wife Beth (Erika Henningsen) and Barbara (Whitney Bashor), longtime friend of Eddie's brother Billy (Aaron C. Finley). Maria Egler also gets one standout scene as Eddie's mother.

Unlike the movie, the musical frames the story as a memory piece narrated by John Schiappa as the older and wiser version of Boogie. The device keeps the show running smoothly from one scene to the next, but it also tips off the audience that Boogie won't suffer too much from his bad choices. Another weakness is that some of the scenes, and a few of the songs, stop dead without resolving themselves, but that should be fairly easy to resolve.

Derek McLane's scenic design, adapted by James Kronzer, moves sleekly when needed and converts itself from the title diner into a variety of other settings, most amusingly a jail.

Signature Theatre
Diner
December 9 - January 25, 2015
Book by Barry Levinson
Music & lyrics by Sheryl Crow
Produced with permission of Warner Bros. Theatre Ventures Inc.
Based on the motion picture produced by Jerry Weintraub and written and directed by Barry Levinson
Older Boogie: John Schiappa
Modell: Bryan Fenkart
Eddie: Adam Kantor
Shrevie: Josh Grisetti
Fenwick: Matthew James Thomas
Elyse: Tess Soltau
Beth: Erika Henningsen
Boogie: Derek Klena
Bagel: John Schiappa
Eddie's Mother: Maria Egler
Billy: Aaron C. Finley
Barbara: Whitney Bashor
Carol Heathrow: Colleen Hayes
Howard: Lou Steele
Methan: Mitch Marois
Salon Receptionist: MaryLee Adams
Tank: Russell Sunday
Eddie's Father: John Leslie Wolfe
Stripper: Nova Y. Payton
Doo-Wop Guys: Ben Lurye, Mitch Marois, David Rowen, Lou Steele
Ensemble: MaryLee Adams, Maria Egler, Colleen Hayes, Ben Lurye, Mitch Marois, Nova Y. Payton, David Rowen, Lou Steele, Russell Sunday, John Leslie Wolfe
Directed and choreographed by Kathleen Marshall
Music direction by Lon Hoyt
MAX Theatre, 4200 Campbell Ave.
Arlington, VA 22206
Ticket Information: 703-820-9771 or 1-800-955-5566 or www.signature-theatre.org


Photo: Carol Rosegg