Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: St. Louis

Good People
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis


R. Ward Duffy and Denise Cormier
One hundred and fifty-two years ago, Charles Dickens began the publication of "Great Expectations." And now another great storyteller, David Lindsay-Abaire, takes up the opposite theme in a story with just as much humor and fright and excitement, in what you might call "Diminished Expectations": about our own modern, fragmenting economy.

It may sound like two hours of the "dismal science," but you can keep all those great expectations you've brought in with you, because they'll all be amply rewarded.

Seth Gordon directs this story of an irresistible "Southie" woman from the blue-collar side of Boston (Denise Cormier). And, over the course of two hours, she pushes on, even when it seems she's born to be stripped of every tiny success that comes her way. Is it funny? You bet. Touching? Yes. Frightening? Very much so. And yet, like any good Dickens yarn, every bit as harrowing, and uplifting, and unexpected, too.

It all starts out in a grimy alley behind a dollar store where Margaret (Ms. Cormier) is getting fired from a lousy job by her anguished but businesslike boss, played by Aaron Orion Baker. Wracking her brains for another way to keep a roof over her daughter's head, she begins a feisty journey to one of the nicest parts of Boston (Chestnut Hill) and an exceedingly tricky confrontation with a Southie boy who made good. Their whole second act resonates with a whimsical sense of conspiracy and even a strangely charming kind of sexual despotism (in spite of the dire ramifications).

Before that, though, we learn a lot about the disparate moral templates of the rich and the poor—Margaret's handicapped daughter blasts "Judge Judy" through their rooming house (a fantasy on judgment and retribution) and later Margaret will meet her old flame (the perfect leading man—on the surface—R. Ward Duffy), who at least seems to let a high-priced marriage counselor define his own moral landscape. But, one way or another, it's the story of burgeoning empire, not terribly different from the way Dickens or Shaw might have told it, if they'd had a Lindsay-Abaire's modern sense of humor.

We first meet Mr. Duffy's character Mike (who runs a high-priced fertility clinic) in a steel-and-glass office, with an overwhelming view of downtown Boston. Margaret is at once clever and pathetic, trading quips and memories with this silver-fox doctor and, one way or another, she ends up in his perfect home, with his perfect wife and child, in the second half.

There's a brilliant awkwardness, a fumbling for the truth with numbed fingertips, all the way through, and lots of bracing talk closing in on the most unspeakable topic in America: social standing and economic class. And Mr. Duffy's young on-stage wife Kate (the quietly tragic, and delightful, Zoey Martinson) has some pretty memorable throwaway lines to fill-out their relationship as well. But the flashiest verbal swordplay is still between Margaret and Mike. Most of the women I know will delight in her ability to put him in the hot-seat, now and then.

Andrea Gallo and Elizabeth Ann Townsend, as Dottie and Jean, are hilarious, too, helping Margaret thrash her way through to the truth, from that rooming house kitchen, and a church basement where they huddle over a slew of bingo cards.

In the end, we have to decide how our economy really works, given the inevitable human element—and whether the "Melting Pot" theory of American Exceptionalism is really all it's cracked-up to be—if anyone ever really rises to greatness, without some sort of gross malfeasance. And yet, somehow, great artists put it all in perspective: the pain and the privilege; along with the shared martyrdom of kindred spirits. A consistently surprising and outstanding show.

Through January 27, 2013, at the Browning Mainstage of the Loretto-Hilton Center for the Performing Arts, 130 Edgar Rd. in Webster Groves, MO. For more information visit www.repstl.org or call (314) 968-4925.

Cast
Margaret: Denise Cormier
Stevie: Aaron Orion Baker
Dottie: Andrea Gallo
Jean: Elizabeth Ann Townsend
Mike: R. Ward Duffy
Kate: Zoey Martinson

Production Credits
Director: Seth Gordon
Costume Designer: Kent Dorsey
Costume Designer: Myrna Colley-Lee
Lighting Designer: Michael Lincoln
Sound Designer: Rusty Wandall
Casting: Rich Cole
Stage Manager: Champe Leary
Assistant Stage Manager: Tony Dearing
Production Manager: Edward M. Coffield
Technical Director: Nichelle Kramlich Williams
Assistant Technical Director: Emilie Weilbacher-McMullan
Materials Coordinator: Mike Dowdy
Charge Scenic Artist: Scott Loebl
Scenic Artists: Stephen Pollihan, James Van Well
Scenic Shop Foreman: Dan Roach
Scenic Carpenters: Dave McCarthy, Richard Shetley, Danny Steinbrook
Master Electrician: Christina Beck
Master Sound Technician: Michael Ferguson
Studio Electrician: William Leach
Studio Sound Technician: Robert Thompson
Props Master: Kelly Kreutsberg
Props Carpenter: Ralph Wilke
Costume Shop Manager: Marci Franklin
Costume Shop Assistant/Bookkeeper: Susan Byrd
Head Crafts Artisan: Garth Dunbar
Head Draper: Robert W. Trump
Draper: Elizabeth Eisloeffel
First Hands: Sandra Kabuye, Patty Macdonnell-Smith
Mainstage Wardrobe Supervisor: Rissa Crozier
Studio Wardrobe Supervisor: Michelle McClees
Wig Supervisor: John Metzner
Costume Rental Coordinator: Michelle McClees

Photo by Jerry Naunheim, Jr.


-- Richard T. Green