Why are people so surprised by the good reviews? There was a tremendous amount of talent involved in the creative team. And the final product was excellent. I loved it. But whether it survives or not, I have no idea.
I was surprised because I LOATHE the source material. I saw it in Chicago because of a friend in the ensemble, but wasn't expecting to enjoy it at all, and was very surprised by the reception to it, and my own response, which was favorable.