LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

re: Alfie D. a villain?
Last Edit: PlayWiz 06:35 pm EDT 04/06/18
Posted by: PlayWiz 06:34 pm EDT 04/06/18
In reply to: re: Alfie D. a villain? - Michael_Portantiere 03:28 pm EDT 04/06/18

I think Doolittle implies that he has threatened Eliza with a strap in the past, not necessarily hit her with one. Eliza also mentions in the text that she has had a black eye before, but that's not necessarily from her father -- it could have been in school, with another flower girl trying to move in on her turf, etc. It's possible that Doolittle hit her to keep her disciplined, but years ago corporal punishment at least here in the U.S. was legal -- not sure about the UK. Also, not sure if one whack would be considered excessive, though nowadays with some parenting advocates it might be.
reply to this message


re: Alfie D. a villain?
Posted by: Michael_Portantiere 08:20 pm EDT 04/06/18
In reply to: re: Alfie D. a villain? - PlayWiz 06:34 pm EDT 04/06/18

Again, I think what Alfie Doolittle says indicates quite clearly that he hit her with a strap in the past as a form of discipline, presumably during her childhood. I'm not sure why some people are so resistant to this interpretation when it seems so clear, but I guess it's because they don't like to think of Eliza's father doing that to her, because they like to think of him as a more benign, roguishly lovable character.
reply to this message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.007481 seconds.