LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

re: Renee Fleming and awards season
Last Edit: Delvino 09:12 pm EDT 04/07/18
Posted by: Delvino 09:10 pm EDT 04/07/18
In reply to: Renee Fleming and awards season - ARReith1982 06:26 pm EDT 04/07/18

She's good in "Carousel," but she's following some wonderful women in the role who made equal, or bigger impressions. Comparisons are odious and also inevitable. I don't think this is a performance that would go down in theater history, save the footnote, i.e. the presence of a major opera diva's career switch (yes, I know she did the flop play; this is Fleming singing, and one of musical theater's most famous and moving songs.)

I predict no Tony nomination, but respectful and respectable reviews.
reply to this message


re: Renee Fleming and awards season
Last Edit: garyd 12:37 am EDT 04/08/18
Posted by: garyd 12:35 am EDT 04/08/18
In reply to: re: Renee Fleming and awards season - Delvino 09:10 pm EDT 04/07/18

Denyce Graves played/sang Nettie in the Chicago Lyric Opera production and was fine. Ms. Fleming is also fine. The role is often, even in the original, essayed by a mezzo soprano our opera diva for the obvious requirements of the song. The problem with the Chicago production was that Princess Cruise ship lumbering in the background of Soliloquy. No one has ever been able to explain that one to me.
reply to this message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.007985 seconds.