I more or less agree with you -- and I'm a Yazbek fan. I'm also a fan of the movie and found it much more rewarding than the musical. Where the movie was subtle, wry and warm, the stage version is broad, unfocused and rather dull.
The accolades likely have to do with it being a rare musical for adults. And it's a weak season for new musicals, so it's easy to stand out. (Yes, I realize the rave reviews came early in the season, and even earlier if you consider the off-Broadway run.)
A disappointment for me, and I really wanted to love it. I did love the song "Answer Me" and agree that Katrina Lenk is fascinating. Wish there were more to love. |
