LOG IN / REGISTER




re: LA TRAVIATA at the Met - tonight
Posted by: JAS 12:56 pm EST 12/05/18
In reply to: re: LA TRAVIATA at the Met - tonight - Michael_Portantiere 12:28 pm EST 12/05/18

That’s a good question, Michael, but I don’t know how Verdi felt. While I agree that Germont’s cabaletta is pretty forgettable, Violetta’s second verse to “Ah, fors e lui” is kind of important to understanding her psyche, as is Alfredo’s cabaletta. Plus, when Alfredo’s cabaletta is cut, it necessitates an added bit of non Verdi music or just cuts abruptly to Violetta’s entrance. Both solutions damage the structure.

As for the 150 years of cutting, I understand, but longevity does not equate “good” or “satisfactory.” Remember: they used to routinely cut the norn scene and the Waltraute scene as well in Götterdämmerung!
reply

Previous: re: LA TRAVIATA at the Met - tonight - Michael_Portantiere 12:28 pm EST 12/05/18
Next: re: LA TRAVIATA at the Met - tonight - Michael_Portantiere 12:59 pm EST 12/05/18
Thread:

Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.010819 seconds.