For me the oddest comment was, "The score by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul is powerful and energetic. Though it's not exceptionally tuneful, and not a cast recording I'd buy or listen to later,"
The score to DEH is not tuneful? I think it has some of the most beautiful and unforgettable tunes of any musical in the past few years. Nearly every song is a winner. There are some tunes from this show that have a hard time leaving my head.