You would be forgiven for thinking you are alone notwithstanding the review of the often-contrarian in the WSJ; it's behind a paywall after all. But how can you expect mercy for not knowing the review published on this very site concluded the play wasn't much to shout about? FWIW I liked the play and I don't like the "am I alone" device. Regarding the noisy neighbors, I recommend meditation. I don't know how one can think of surviving in New York without it.