I saw it in November, and thought Andy Karl, Orfeh and the other principals matched Barks in performance. Overall, not being a fan of the film, the show was well performed but unmemorable.
Very good point. I should have been more clear Andy, Orfeh and other principals were terrific. I had heard from lot of people that Samantha was okayish but I thought that she was quite good. I was referring more to some of the folks in the ensemble/chorus.