LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

re: No debacle. You have to be careful about books that "mix fact and fiction."
Posted by: Delvino 10:04 am EDT 08/01/20
In reply to: re: No debacle. You have to be careful about books that "mix fact and fiction." - keikekaze 10:37 pm EDT 07/31/20

And the Wildcat vocals -- which I grew up hearing -- don't create that Mame sound. She sang with what can only be described as more confidence. To my ear, she sounds better than two famous Bacall notes "aliiiiiiive" and "womaaaaan," though admittedly the two actors had different personas/temperaments while singing. I always thought Bacall got a pass rather easily, and sounds good on only one number, "I Wrote the Book" in Woman of the Year. Coleman seemed more adept at writing for the Ball range than Strouse or Kander/Ebb did for Bacall, who would've been better off without that top of the voice screech. Just my two pennies.
reply to this message


re: No debacle. You have to be careful about books that "mix fact and fiction."
Posted by: Michael_Portantiere 11:50 am EDT 08/01/20
In reply to: re: No debacle. You have to be careful about books that "mix fact and fiction." - Delvino 10:04 am EDT 08/01/20

"And the Wildcat vocals -- which I grew up hearing -- don't create that Mame sound. She sang with what can only be described as more confidence."

Well, yes. Largely because, by the time of MAME, her voice had deteriorated much, much further from its best shape than it had by the time of WILDCAT. If Lucy had somehow been able to use a time machine and play either of those roles in her late twenties or early thirties, I'm pretty sure she would have sounded far better.
reply to this message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.008669 seconds.