LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

re: To my great-grandmother...
Posted by: JereNYC (JereNYC@aol.com) 10:54 am EDT 03/18/21
In reply to: re: To my great-grandmother... - Chromolume 09:37 pm EDT 03/17/21

Audiences didn't have to wonder how Major General Stanley got all those many daughters...the lyric reveals that.

"We are Wards In Chancery, and Father is a Major General."

So these women are not the Major General's biological daughters, they are his wards. They were put in his care by the Court of Chancery. They refer to him as "Father" and seem to genuinely care for him, but it's also possible that they have been in his care for many years at the point we meet them.

Without anything in the text to support the idea, I've assumed that these women were placed in his care as children because he was a wealthy person with the means to support them and the willingness to do so. All of these people seem to consider themselves to be a family, despite none of them likely being biologically related to any of the others.
reply to this message


re: To my great-grandmother...
Posted by: Chromolume 02:25 pm EDT 03/18/21
In reply to: re: To my great-grandmother... - JereNYC 10:54 am EDT 03/18/21

"We are Wards In Chancery, and Father is a Major General."

Thank you for the reminder. having done Pirates a number of times, I'm surprised I forgot that, especially as Gilbert daringly rhymes "chancery" with "caravanserai." ;-)

I still stand by the idea that Gilbert could be quite suggestive when he wanted to be. Perhaps a better example would be the way the (highly susceptible) Lord Chancellor in Iolanthe overtly lusts after his very own wards in chancery. Oops...
reply to this message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.008260 seconds.