LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

re: "Charlie Girl" and "Salad Days" - both long West End runs - why not Broadway?
Posted by: scoot1er 01:48 pm EDT 07/10/21
In reply to: re: "Charlie Girl" and "Salad Days" - both long West End runs - why not Broadway? - BroadwayTonyJ 10:27 am EDT 07/10/21

I saw Robert and Elizabeth in a gorgeous production at Paper Mill in either the late 70s or early 80s. I had always loved the score and was anxious to see it. As I recall—and it was a long time ago—it was old fashioned even then and seemed to be firmly planted in operetta territory. I don’t know if that production was intended as a Broadway tryout, but if it were, it was also clear why it didn’t transfer. A pity as the score and production were beautiful.
reply to this message


Robert and Elizabeth
Posted by: peter3053 03:36 pm EDT 07/12/21
In reply to: re: "Charlie Girl" and "Salad Days" - both long West End runs - why not Broadway? - scoot1er 01:48 pm EDT 07/10/21

Robert and Elizabeth made for pretty strong stuff for an operetta - a father's mental abuse of his daughter and oppressive dominance of his family. Also, there was a modern, early 60s (therefore, at the time contemporary) sensibility of rebellion through it. Also, musical montage sequences, one in Act One which I would say had a filmic quality (according to what is described in the script). The Soliloquy by Elizabeth which opens Act Two is the equal of any of the greatest of musical theater songs. And in the original production, the finale which had the train arriving, coming at the audience, is said by those who saw it to have been wonderful.

Eminently revivable, but would need money and canny casting, I suspect.
reply to this message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.008471 seconds.