LOG IN / REGISTER




re: What?....
Posted by: portenopete 04:45 pm EDT 10/06/21
In reply to: re: What?.... - JT 02:44 pm EDT 10/06/21

The tradition of casting Mrs. Brice: Kay Medford, Maureen Stapleton, Tyne Daly, Jayne Houdyshell: not one of them was/is Jewish.

Who cares? They were- to varying degrees- all great. (Any record of Lillian Roth? Was she any better?)

Valerie Harper and Nancy Walker were both shiksas who played probably the most iconic Jewish characters in mid-century American TV.

The most-celebrated anti-Semite and anti-Catholic character Archie Bunker (and his UK equivalent Alf Garnett) were played by a Jew and a Catholic!

Sean Penn was a deeply moving and accurate (as far as I can tell) Harvey Milk.

I think it's great and adds verisimilitude when a role is played by someone with a lived experience similar to their character. And it's a good thing to open up the acting opportunities for marginalised communities.

But "offensive"? Does a murderer have a right to gripe when they cast- as they inevitably do- a non-murderer as Jack the Ripper? Or a non-vampire as Dracula?
reply

Previous: re: What?....Beanie Feldstein is the lead - Thom915 06:41 pm EDT 10/06/21
Next: re: Maureen Stapleton, Tyne Daly, Jayne Houdyshell did BIRDIE not FG - champagnesalesman 12:23 am EDT 10/07/21
Thread:

Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.038075 seconds.