LOG IN / REGISTER



Threaded Order Chronological Order

In any other year, sure.
Posted by: ShowGoer 06:54 pm EST 12/27/21
In reply to: re: Broadway cast recordings for COMPANY or SIX? - BroadwayTonyJ 11:38 am EST 12/27/21

“ When I was in New York (Nov. 16 -- 21), Six was sold out and offering standing room so that's a good sign that the show is on track to recoup.”

That would probably be true if not for what’s going on in the wired right now. In the long run you may be right, but for now I’d have to say “not necessarily”. My guess is that SIX is capitalized to recoup selling out its theater for between 10 and 12 months (just a guess) – but if they have a few months of slightly smaller houses (almost certainly what lies ahead in Jan-Feb even if not for Omicron), plus 1-2 weeks here and there of completely lost performances (as is happening right now), then instead of recouping by next fall if it sells out, that target likely gets pushed to sometime in early 2023 instead (assuming it sells out from, say, April through the rest of the calendar year).

A useful comparison point for a small musical with 6 actors would be a small splashy but expensive play with 3 actors - as I’ve written elsewhere, “The Lehman Trilogy” was poised to almost certainly break even during its limited run in pre-Covid times. As things now stand though, it will now end its scheduled dates next week having only recouped close to 70% of its investment instead. (The corollary being, if Lehman had hypothetically been able to scrape through the winter, play through the awards season, and have another strong 3-4 months between March and June, it presumably might have broken even by the summer… instead of when they needed it to, which was now.)
reply to this message


re: In any other year, sure.
Posted by: BroadwayTonyJ 09:00 pm EST 12/27/21
In reply to: In any other year, sure. - ShowGoer 06:54 pm EST 12/27/21

I agree with everything you are saying. Of all the shows on Broadway right now, Six has the best shot at recouping because its running costs are low, it's popular, and IMO it's a good show. Others on this board probably disagree. However, the future is very uncertain, and no one at this point really knows anything.

Broadway cast recordings, especially those released on CD, generally cost anywhere from $350,000 to $500,000 and rarely turn a profit. Over the last 25 years I would guess that Rent, The Producers, Hamilton, and possibly The Book of Mormon and In the Heights made money -- maybe a few others but I would have to do a little research before naming more shows. Six and Company already have cast albums on CD so it all depends on their productions or generous donors if they want to spend the money for a Broadway recording. That's hard to predict. The announcement of a cast album for the Caroline, Or Change revival was a very welcome and happy occurrence, just IMO.
reply to this message


re: In any other year, sure.
Posted by: Chromolume 10:00 pm EST 12/27/21
In reply to: re: In any other year, sure. - BroadwayTonyJ 09:00 pm EST 12/27/21

But of course a new recording is never guaranteed. I still think it's a shame they never did one of the (multi Tony-winning) original Broadway Falsettos, instead just repackaging the off-Broadway recordings of each piece as a "new" double CD. Even though by that time the material had changed a good deal. It would have been nice to get an official record of that cast and those changes at the time.
reply to this message | reply to first message


re: In any other year, sure.
Last Edit: BroadwayTonyJ 11:48 pm EST 12/27/21
Posted by: BroadwayTonyJ 11:41 pm EST 12/27/21
In reply to: re: In any other year, sure. - Chromolume 10:00 pm EST 12/27/21

I'm pretty happy with the 2 off-Broadway cast recordings which were combined into a unit. As much as I love the show itself as seen on stage, I rarely listen to the show's recording, but that's just me. Nevertheless, I prefer the original set of recordings to that of the '16 revival. I thought the '19 tour of the revival was better cast and acted than the '16 Broadway version.

My biggest regret is the lack of a cast recording for the Broadway or touring productions of James Joyce's The Dead. It was my favorite new musical that season and I thought the score (sung by that incredible cast) was haunting. I was told that 2 different labels were in negotiations for respectively the Broadway and tour productions, but they couldn't close the deal for either. The cast album of the Pittsburgh Irish & Classical Theatre production was an acceptable substitute, but I really miss hearing the renditions of Howes, Nixon, Brown or Prince, Ripley, Skinner, Walken or Bogardus, Spinella, and the others.
reply to this message | reply to first message


Privacy Policy


Time to render: 0.012541 seconds.