He is.
By many. He’s technically far above a Jerry Herman, for example, and I don’t care what snobbery abounds regarding hits and such. The fact is this question is inflammatory and is not really fair.
His work has touched millions, has actually saved a life (mine) and is interesting (not always equally so).
Some of his shows are pure fun, some are weak, some rank among the greatest ever written.
His shifting meter is consistently interesting, at times revealing.
Is he Rodgers (his idol)? No. Is he the equal to a Sondheim? Of course not. And thank god.
But, at least in my life and family, he is as equally loved.
And I think that’s what actually matters. |
