Threaded Order Chronological Order
| re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. | |
| Posted by: theatreguy40 05:15 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
| In reply to: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. - kieran 08:12 pm EDT 04/04/23 | |
|
|
|
| I saw the production when it played at St. Ann's Warehouse. Appalling - to say the least. While the director and cast constantly decried that "not a word has been changed" -- well that may be -- but the stage directions (written by the playwright Oscar Hammerstein) certainly have. Jud's death is completely the invention of director Daniel Fish and goes totally against what Oscar Hammerstein had written. So in a sense while a "word" may not have been changed, the intentions of the playwright certainly have! The whole current revival has twisted the show completely out of shape to make it what Daniel Fish wants and not what the writers intended. Whatever "themes" or "ideas" that Fish wanted to explore should have been explored with a NEW piece and not try to shoe-horn it or force it into an existing play. I believe that's why most audiences rebell against the current revival. And the ballet --- totally incomprehensible in meaning to most audiences --- again, trying to say something that was never intended by the original writers... Just my 2 cents (and many many many others as well) |
|
| reply to this message |
| re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. | |
| Posted by: jo 09:27 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
| In reply to: re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. - theatreguy40 05:15 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
|
|
|
| You've probably captured the sentiment of audiences which did not agree with the revisal by Daniel Fish. OKLAHOMA! is not just America's landmark musical but it has also become a cultural treasure of America, not just for the glorious music and original staging from Rodgers & Hammerstein ( based on Lynn Riggs play "Green Grow The Lilacs") but because it touched a certain slice of history & culture in the settling of the West. I was lucky to have seen the RNT Oklahoma! in London after it had transferred from the South Bank. I was in London on a business trip and when I learned that there was a revival of one of my favorite composers' famous musicals, I got tickets for the show. I did not even know who the cast was - I was just thankful to see a live staging of the film version which I saw in the past. To be honest, it was my least favorite of their 5 famous musicals ( most of which I saw only in film adaptations) because it was not well-acted by some members of the cast . The RNT Oklahoma had explored some dark nuances not obvious in the original show/film adaptation, without necessarily changing the artistic intention of the famous composers. The characters showed some of these dark nuances which Nunn said he had gleaned from the R&H musical play. Thankfully it was filmed on a sound stage ( scenes from a staging were spliced in) at the initiative of Trevor Nunn...and the home video included a long Behind-the-scenes feature, which added appreciation of the Nunn revival. Take the time to watch that Special Feature and appreciate more of how a classic can be revived with new nuances but still being essentially true to the original artistic intentions. If Mr. Fish wanted to project a different look at the culture and mores then, he should have written his OWN musical theatre composition and not appropriate a well-loved classic to project his artistic intentions. There is room for modern or avant garde thinking, even about what happened in the past, but this was not the right way to do it, as far as I am concerned. |
|
| reply to this message |
| re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. | |
| Posted by: AlanScott 10:24 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
| In reply to: re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. - jo 09:27 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
|
|
|
| The film version of Oklahoma! is my favorite Rodgers and Hammerstein film, followed closely by Flower Drum Song. I think it's the best directed film version of a Rodgers and Hammerstein musical and is extremely well cast. In fact, it's probably my favorite film of any Broadway musical. I was not wild about the Nunn production, at least not in its New York incarnation and the filming of the London production. The scene where Eller gives Laurey a dress was an addition that I would guess was written by Nunn. It's not in the show and it's not in Green Grow the Lilacs. |
|
| reply to this message | reply to first message |
| re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. | |
| Posted by: jo 10:49 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
| In reply to: re: “Oklahoma!”: Audience Rejection On the Road. - AlanScott 10:24 pm EDT 04/06/23 | |
|
|
|
| To each his own! I liked SOUTH PACIFIC the best of all the film adaptations as it had the most dramatic storyline compared to the others. It is a movie that can do well with a remake now because the geopolitical conflict that existed then now also exists but with slightly different players...plus the theme of racism and cultural conflicts were well-explored then. The music is dramatic, romantic, playful and with some soul-searching themes. |
|
| reply to this message | reply to first message |
Time to render: 0.029404 seconds.