Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Washington, D.C.

Judgment at Nuremberg
American Century Theater

Michael Replogle and Craig Miller
Judgment at Nuremberg, the current production of American Century Theater in Arlington, Virginia, is an important story with strong acting, incisive direction, and an unfortunately awkward script. Abby Mann's 2001 play began as a television drama in 1959 and a movie in 1961, and onstage it plays rather choppily as individual scenes bridged by musical cues and shifts in lighting.

Following World War II, the Allies conducted trials against Nazi leaders in the German city of Nuremberg. The play concerns a subsequent tribunal that charged four Nazi-era judges with crimes against humanity for their perversions of the judicial process. These trials brought up many ethical issues still being discussed, including the question of how they differ from "show trials" with predetermined verdicts; whether they provide a legal excuse for the victors in a war to further punish and humiliate the losers; and—most germane here—whether they intrude on another country's legal system by determining that obeying an unjust law is itself illegal. (Jack Marshall, artistic director of American Century Theater, is a legal ethicist by profession who has organized pre- and post-show discussions addressing these topics.)

Director Joe Banno keeps the human drama in the forefront, never allowing the arguments to become legal abstractions. It's about Judge Haywood (Craig Miller), a civilian jurist with no experience in international law; Colonel Lawson (Bruce Alan Rauscher), the feverishly determined prosecutor; Ernst Janning (Michael Replogle), the most esteemed of the four defendants; and Oscar Rolfe (Steve Lebens), the defense attorney prepared to do what he must to ensure that his clients receive a fair trial. Ron Sarro, Karin Rosnizeck, Christopher Henley, and Mary Beth Luckenbaugh shine in smaller roles.

Banno has added another layer to the drama: silent "ghost" figures of the Jewish defendants and Nazi soldiers who earlier dealt with the judges now facing their own judgment in the same courtroom. While this device may sound precious or overly sentimental, it is used judiciously and never overshadows the action of the play.

Patrick Lord has designed a straightforward courtroom set, with audience seating on two facing sides, and the atmospheric projections that add specificity to individual moments. Marc Allan Wright's lighting design ties the scenes together with cinematic dissolves from one part of the stage to another.

American Century Theater
Judgment at Nuremberg
May 30th - June 28th
By Abby Mann
Colonel Lawson: Bruce Alan Rauscher
General Merrin: Lyle Blake Smythers
Judge Haywood: Craig Miller
Captain Byers: Jorge A. Silva
Judge Ives: Tel Monks
Judge Norris: Paul J. Klingenberg
Emil Hahn: Kim Curtis
Frederick Hoffstetter: Tom Fuller
Werner Lammpe: Victor Gold
Ernst Janning: Michael Replogle
Oscar Rolfe: Steve Lebens
Dr. Wickert: Ron Sarro
Mrs. Halbestadt: Ellie Nicoll
Frau Bertholt: Karin Rosnizeck
Rudolph Peterson: Christopher Henley
Dr. Gueter: Larry Kolp
Maria Wallner: Mary Beth Luckenbaugh
Elsa Lindnow: Vanessa Bradchulis
Feldenstein: Jay Delehanty
Ensemble: Alan Diaz, Paul Alan Hogan, Colin Martin, Jean H. Miller, Lynley Peoples, Gray West
Directed by Joe Banno
Gunston Theatre II, 2700 S. Lang St.
Arlington, VA 22206
Ticket Information: 703-998-4555 or

Photo: Johannes Markus

Also see the Current Theatre Season Calendar for D.C.