Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Washington, D.C.

Elmer Gantry
Signature Theatre

Also see Susan's reviews of Sex with Strangers and Fetch Clay, Make Man


Charlie Pollock
The musical version of Sinclair Lewis' Elmer Gantry has been around in one form or another for many years, including two productions at Ford's Theatre. Now, Signature Theatre in Arlington, Virginia, and director Eric Schaeffer have brought the show back to the Washington area, with substantial changes but the same timeless topic—religious fervor and where it intersects with show business.

Charlie Pollock smolders rather than burns in the title role; he has the spirit, but his preaching is less about hellfire, more about comforting people making do in hard times.

When the audience first meets Elmer Gantry, he's a traveling salesman struggling to make a living in dusty Midwestern towns during the Depression. He did study for the ministry, but gave up his calling when his congregation learned about his earthier tastes. When he meets the determined evangelist Sharon Falconer (Mary Kate Morrissey) and her ragtag revival troupe, he decides to return to the way of righteousness—and make some money along the way. Elmer, with his salesman's instincts, dresses up the choir and brings in three roof-raising African-American gospel singers, and pretty soon the crowds start growing.

Morrissey imbues Sharon with a drive that manifests itself in both spiritual and carnal ways. She and Pollock are an equal match, neither one dominating the other, although the power shifts between them. Nova Y. Payton, with her glorious voice, unsurprisingly walks off with every scene she appears in as the leader of the gospel trio, while Lawrence Redmond amuses as a civic leader who worships both football and God. Bobby Smith brings backbone to the non-singing role of Elmer's old friend from the seminary.

The tuneful score by Mel Marvin (music) and Bob Satuloff (lyrics) is strongest in its gospel numbers performed by a spirited chorus. John Bishop, the original book writer, died in 2006 after almost completing a revised script; his widow, Lisa, also contributed material to the final version.

Karma Camp's choreography keeps the action in constant motion, and music director Vadim Feichtner gets a robust sound from a talented 10-piece orchestra.

Signature Theatre
Elmer Gantry
October 7th - November 9th
Book by John Bishop
Additional book material by Lisa Bishop
Music by Mel Marvin
Lyrics by Bob Satuloff
Based on the novel by Sinclair Lewis
Stationmaster: Harry A. Winter
Elmer Gantry: Charlie Pollock
Salesmen:
Shartel: Russell Sunday
Dave: Stephen Gregory Smith
Paul: Paul Scanlan
Will: Sean Burns
Sharon Falconer: Mary Kate Morrissey
Troupe:
Tom: Nick Lehan
Shirley: Bayla Whitten
Art: Matt Conner
Martin: William Diggle
Paula: Jessica Lauren Ball
Maude: Maria Egler
Bernice: Jamie Eacker
Henry: Harry A. Winter
Forrest: Russell Sunday
Michael: Sean Burns
Ray: Paul Scanlan
Frankie: Stephen Gregory Smith
Mary Washington: Nova Y. Payton
Epatha Washington: Ashley Buster
Grace Washington: Daphne Epps
Bellboy: Sean Burns
Frank Shallard: Bobby Smith
Merle Blanchard: Lawrence Redmond
Mother: Jamie Eacker
Father: Russell Sunday
Young Man: Ian Berlin
Bob Faucher: Harry A. Winter
Mike Carrigan: Russell Sunday
Russ Kohler: Paul Scanlan
Emmitt Timmons: Stephen Gregory Smith
Directed by Eric Schaeffer
Choreography by Karma Camp
Music direction by Vadim Feichtner
MAX Theatre, 4200 Campbell Ave.
Arlington, VA 22206
Ticket Information: 703-820-9771 or 1-800-955-5566 or www.signature-theatre.org


Photo: Margot Schulman