Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Philadelphia

The Puzzle
Hedgerow Theatre
Review by Rebecca Rendell

Also see Rebecca's recent reviews of Chicken & Biscuits and Written by Phillis

David Shiner, Daniel Passer, and Michael Stahler
Photo by Mark Garvin
The Hedgerow Theatre recently presented the world premiere of Juliette Dunn's imaginative and thought-provoking The Puzzle. The play is a beautiful tribute to the rich inner lives of non-speakers with autism and the magic that happens when they are given the opportunity to make meaningful connections in their own unique ways. In this production, the new work still had ample room for improvement, but the small cast shared an authentic connection that was mesmerizing.

The Puzzle does not have a traditional story structure, but rather functions as a fluid and surreal series of events. It begins with a two clowns, Finneas and Quinton, living out a sort of loop in their strange scrap-yard home. The pair are finally about to complete a jigsaw puzzle (or are they?), but their plans are upended when a non-verbal young man wanders into their space and unintentionally hides several crucial pieces of the puzzle. The Boy forces Finneas and Quinton to rethink the way they communicate and eventually allows them to shift the way they experience the world around them. The unexpected blend of clowning and neurodivergence delivers a powerful message about the power of empathy and connection.

Professional clown Daniel Passer was captivating as upbeat Finneas, bringing an authentic sense of fun and wonder to the production. David Shiner portrayed his foil Quinton with a relatable sense of skepticism and frustration. Arguing, conspiring, and retelling the same jokes, the vibe between Passer and Shiner was somewhere between an old married couple and the characters from a Beckett play. Co-directors David Shiner and Bill Fennelly clearly gave the cast ample freedom to play, and the drama was best when Passer and Shiner were just clowning around with each other and Michael Stahler.

Stahler explicitly drew on his experience as an autistic actor to play The Boy and his performance was stellar. Every interaction Stahler had with the "clowns"–and with Shawn Fisher's darkly creative set–was full of meaning and soul. Unfortunately, the slow pace and lack of narrative progress ultimately made for a disjointed and slow-moving experience despite the best efforts of this talented cast and creative team. I would love to see another production of The Puzzle that keeps the genuine interaction and insight into non-verbal individuals, but tightens up the pace and improves the narrative flow.

The Puzzle had an extended run through June 4, 2023, at the at Hedgerow Theatre, 64 Rose Valley Rd, Media PA. For more information, visit

David Shiner: Quinton
Daniel Passer: Finneas
Michael Stahler: The Boy

Co-Directors: David Shiner And Bill Fennelly
Lighting Designer: Lily Fossner
Scenic Designer: Shawn Fisher
Costume Designer: Rebecca Kanach
Choreographer: Karen Getz
Dramaturg: Wendy Babel
Fight Director: Sean Mcgarry
Piano: Joe Gribbin
Drumming: Alex_the_Listener
Production Manager: Kate Fossner
Intimacy Consultation: Kelsey H├ębert