Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: St. Louis

Talley's Folly
The New Jewish Theatre

Also see Richard's review of The Divine Sister

Shaun Sheley and
Meghan Maguire

Romance may never get more personal than this, as two splendid actors reason out their future on a dreamy riverbank, under a clear-eyed moon. Not that there's anything "X" or even "PG" rated in Lanford Wilson's famous play—but the steady pursuit of Sally Talley, by a man she met the previous summer, somehow leaves her completely unveiled in every other sense.

Credit director Deana Jent for giving her actors room to spread out and find their perfect size and pace, and Shaun Sheley for somehow becoming irresistible, in spite of being a thoughtful, kindhearted sort of noodge, and also a "dangerous liberal," according to her family (he's a Jewish accountant from St. Louis in 1944). And credit Meghan Maguire for being the Ozarks' great unattainable beauty—who somehow loathes everything about her life, for reasons she makes sure are very difficult to unravel.

Thought and reason, like delicate tools in the hands of Mr. Sheley, work together to gradually create something like a great courtroom drama, till an old heartbreak is revealed along with the same jaw-dropping emotion you get when a witness finally confesses to some heinous crime under cross-examination. Except here, it's one of those moments so intensely personal, directed so beautifully and performed with all the shock of a stark detective novel, that you can almost smell the ozone after a lightning strike.

Producer Kathleen Sitzer calls this show a "valentine" to the community, and it boasts two truly beautiful performances. But it's more of a how-to guide for a long-term relationship, than some slickly designed romance that cynically runs you through a rat's maze of carefully concocted emotional equations, before it spits you out into the lobby again. Instead, there's a constant (almost wary) sort of exploration (in an idyllic setting), and careful examination and re-examination of all sorts of comments and insights and throwaway lines that are held up to reveal each person's character, subtly and gradually, as one should. It's everything that's missing from most great romantic tales, but handled in such a way as to make the reason and rational perfectly indispensible.

It's probably also a great lesson in how to find the right mate, if you can just get them to hang around for an hour and a half of gentle probing, one way or another. It's not so hard if you're in the audience, of course, because you just know, in spite of everything, somehow (against all odds) he's finally going to find a way to break through her mysterious reserve, all the while showing her he's the gentle, open, thoughtful person she needs.

So, it's kind of a miracle of construction, and also of "not saying exactly what you want," too—two things you don't find very often anymore. You just have to have your "relationship ears" on, which is probably the first test of any good potential mate, anyway.

Through December 23, 2012, at the Jewish Community Center, #2 Millstone Campus Drive, on Scheutz Road, just west of Lindbergh (between Olive and Page Blvds.). For information visit or call (314) 442-3283.

Matt Friedman: Shaun Sheley*
Sally Talley: Meghan Maguire

Production Staff
Director: Deanna Jent
Stage Manager: Eric Nathan Brady*
Scenic Designer: Jason Coale
Lighting Designer: Nathan Schroeder
Costume Designer: Michele Friedman Siler
Sound Designer: Robin Weatherall
Properties Master: Peggy Knock
Technical Director: Jerry Russo
Assistant Stage Manager/Wardrobe: Becky Fortner
Scenic Artist: Scott Schoonover
Board Operator: Monica Roscoe
Dialect Coach: Richard Lewis

* Denotes Member, Actors Equity Association, the union of professional actors and stage managers in the US.

Photo: John Lamb

-- Richard T. Green

Privacy Policy