Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Florida - West Coast

My Fair Lady
Asolo Repertory, Sarasota

Andrea Prestinario and Jeff Parker
Asolo Repertory Theater is presenting the classic Lerner and Loewe musical My Fair Lady through December 23, 2011, at the Mertz Theater in the FSU Center. The production is directed by well-known Chicago area actor/director Frank Galati who last year delivered a stunning production of Twelve Angry Men for this theater. For this production, Mr. Galati reached back to his strong Chicago connections for most of his leading cast as well as members of his creative team. The production uses the two piano reduction of the full orchestrations and a small cast. There are plusses and minuses to this approach, the relationships between characters could be more sharply defined in the forced intimacy of the production, and "With a Little Bit of Luck," a perennial showstopper, loses some of its excitement.

My Fair Lady lives or dies on the quality of its Eliza and Henry Higgins. The roles are not easy to cast; I have seen productions where the leads were simply not up to the demands of the parts. The two best leads I have ever seen were in the same production, a National Theater of Great Britain production which toured major musical houses in the US, produced by Cameron Mackintosh and directed by Trevor Nunn. Christopher Cazenove and Lisa O'Hare were the leads. The roles At Asolo Repertory Theater are taken by Andrea Prestinario as Eliza Doolittle and Jeff Parker as Henry Higgins. Both are quite good. Ms. Prestinario joins this production from a run in the same part at Paramount Theater in Chicago, and her experience in the role is a definite plus. Some Elizas are stronger as the Cockney flower girl or as the lady she becomes. Ms. Prestinario is able to play the role as a continuum, moving gradually from one to the other, with reminders of her spitfire past showing through her lady's demeanor. Mr. Parker is an unusual Henry Higgins—the usual bluster is present, but there is a strong undercurrent of romantic leading man. At one point the idea was floated to have Cary Grant play the role in the movie version, and I think Mr. Parker suggests how Mr. Grant might have played the role. Other assets in the company include Andrew Boyer as Alfred P. Doolittle, Sean Effinger-Dean as Freddy Eynsford-Hill, Joel Hatch as Col. Pickering and Rob Lindley, Daniel Schwab, Bryan Torfeh and Robert David May as the four Cockneys who assist Eliza in "Wouldn't It Be Loverly?". In fact, all of the supporting roles are well taken and add much to the buoyancy of the production.

Frank Galati's direction is one of the strongest pieces of this production, showing a clear vision of character and character relationships. He also keeps the action moving along, assisted by Joshua Rhodes as choreographer, and the set design of Russell Metheny. The costumes by Mara Blumenfeld are outstanding. Eliza's yellow ensemble for the Ascot scene and several other outfits are just gorgeous. The musical end of things is in the hands of Doug Peck at Piano 1 and Ian Weinberger at Piano 2.

I highly recommend that anyone who has never seen My Fair Lady on stage and anyone who loves musicals rush to Asolo Repertory Theater's production before it has packed up and gone.

Asolo Repertory Theater presents My Fair Lady through December 23, 2011, at the Mertz Theater in the FSU Center. 5555 N. Tamiami Trail. Sarasota, Florida. Box Office (941) 351-8000. For more information visit

Principal Cast:
Andrea Prestinario as Eliza Doolittle
Jeff Parker as Henry Higgins
Andrew Boyer as Alfred P. Doolittle
Joel Hatch as Col. Pickering
Sean Effinger-Dean as Freddy Eynsford-Hill
Peggy Roeder as Mrs. Higgins
Penny Slusher as Mrs. Pearce

Creative Team:
Frank Galati—Director
Joshua Rhodes—Choreographer
Doug Peck—Music Director
Ian Weinberger—Assistant Music Director
Russell Metheny—Set Design
Mara Blumenfeld—Costume Design
James D. Sale—Lighting Design
Kevin Kennedy—Sound Design
Michelle Hart—Wig & Hair Design
Patricia Delorey—Voice & Dialect
Kelly Borgia—Stage Manager

Photo: Daniel Perales

Be sure to Check the current schedule for theatre in West Coast Florida

See the current season schedule for West Coast Florida

--William S. Oser

Privacy Policy