Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Florida - West Coast

La Bohème
Sarasota Opera
William S. Oser | Season Schedule

Also see Bill's reviews of 2020 Circus Sarasota and American Son

William Davenport, Anna Mandina, Filippo Fontana,
Ricardo Rivera, and Young Bok Kim

Photo by Rod Millington
For many years the ABCs of opera meant Aida, La Bohème and Carmen, the three most often produced operas in America. More recently, producing Aida has fallen away, so Giacomo Puccini's La Bohème, which opens Sarasota Opera's winter festival, is now in the number one slot, and a lovely La Bohème this is. This is a piece that can be a introduction to the world of opera, with several arias familiar from other sources and a love story meltingly told in broad musical strokes. My first La Bohème was over 50 years ago and there have been many in between, but it's been some time since I've seen it, and I returned with a desire to enjoy it once again with fresh ears.

The story finds us in early 1800s Paris, with leading male characters comprising four poor artists: poet Rudolpho; painter Marcello; musician Schaunard; and philosopher Colline. Add in love interests Mimi for Rudolpho and Musetta for Marcello and you have the cast of principals. The story is a bit episodic, but Puccini's sublime music keeps the audience in the know. The arc is Mimi and Rudolpho's relationship from beginning to tragic end.

William Davenport is a lively Rudolpho opposite the exquisite Mimi of Anna Mandina. Davenport has offered Sarasota audiences fine assumptions of The Duke in Rigoletto and both tenor heros in a twin bill of one-act comedies, so his full-voiced Rudolpho is no surprise. "Che gelida manina" is the stop-the-show highlight it is intended to be. Mandina's rise from studio artist to solid principal (previously Liu in Turandot) shows a potential regional star. Her deeply touching Mimi caught me a bit by surprise: The third act "Donde lieta usci" had me in tears. Filippo Fontana, the only native Italian in the cast, brings a nice touch of authenticity and stage presence opposite Jessica Sandidge's Musetta. Ricardo Rivera as Schaunard and Young Bok Kim as Colline complete the principal cast. Among the lesser roles, Adelmo Guidarelli contributes a well-acted landlord Benoit, and Joseph Beutel a cuckolded Alcindoro, enamored with Musetta.

Conductor Victor DeRenzi lovingly presides over this performance, allowing the music to spin out with full emotional impact. His orchestra plays brilliantly for him, the flute trills that define Mimi's yearnings for spring are gorgeously laid into the orchestral texture. Hundreds of other details caught my ear throughout the evening.

A large round of applause goes to stage director Mark Freiman. All of the principals act well, within the known limits of opera acting. His finest moment is in act two, with the stage brimful of chorus, children's chorus, and at the very end drum and bugle, as he creates organized chaos after which everyone moves off stage gracefully. The entire production raises the bar for Sarasota Opera, as a few of the recent productions have not been acted on this level.

Scenic designer David P. Gordon's sets from 2005 are beautiful. The garret for acts one and four feels small and in fact does not utilize the entire stage space, the inner acts equally authentic. It is traditional but not dull. Howard Tsvi Kaplan as costume coordinator, using costumes recently purchased from Malibar, has everyone appropriately dressed, with a stage full of color. Ken Yunker lights with a sure hand, a world of difference between act one winter and act four spring in the garret.

Novice or opera fanatic, this is a fine La Bohème. Sarasota Opera does itself proud.

La Bohème runs through March 21, 2020, at Sarasota Opera, 61 N. Pineapple Avenue, Sarasota FL. For tickets and information call 941-366-8450 or visit

Cast (in order of vocal appearance):
Rudolfo: William Davenport
Marcello: Filippo Fontana
Schaunard: Ricardo Rivera*
Colline: Young Bok Kim
Benoit: Adelmo Guidarelli
Mimi: Anna Mandina
Alcindoro: Joseph Beutel
Musetta: Jessica Sandidge
Parpignol: Kevin Thomas Harvey**
A Customs Sergeant: Jose Cuartas**
Customs Guard: William Huyler**
*= Studio Artist
**=Apprentice Artist