For this is no hand-wringing domestic drama, nor is it a trenchant, tear-jerking tragedy about a bedraggled brood trying to put right what went wrong between them before itís too late. Despite being set in the Transplant Unit of Indiana University Hospital, the play isnít about its stated subjects of father versus daughter or brother versus brother, but really that newly minted, yet already time-worn, conflict of red versus blue.
The latter is represented by Eaton (Christa Kimlicko Jones), a Los Angeles-based philosophy professor whoís thrilled that sheís bypassed her bumpkin upbringing of little education and early motherhood and is instead encouraging young minds; the former is the domain of her father, Blake (John Farrell), who both lives and longs for the simple life (heís into fishing, and not much else) and needs a kidney to live. Given that the only other potential match is his alcoholic brother AJ (Dennis Hearn), thereís never much question from where Blakeís salvation will come.
Evans deserves some credit for not overplaying her hand: Though Eaton has a speech or two about the better parts of the country trying to escape from the questionable core, youíre never exactly beat over the head with direct references to how the endlessly loving and put-upon Coast rescuing the needy, self-important Midwest, which is too busy fighting with itself to do any good for anyone else and is best forgotten or ignored anyway.
But because youíre given no reason to care about any aspect of the familyís troubles, from who will get to donate a kidney to whether Blake will live or die and especially the extent of AJís involvement with Blakeís late wife, thereís no way to dramatically justify any significant portion of the play. AJ and Eaton bicker, Eaton and Blake bicker, Blake and AJ bicker, then Eaton whines about religion, but itís all undirected dissatisfaction. Without much stronger characters grappling with more developed concerns, sitting through their enervating inertia is about as compelling as watching compost decompose.
Jones makes some use of this, injecting a frustrated urgency into her newly re-caged Eaton that almost makes an interesting person from the broken and bent pieces sheís been handed. But Farrell is ceaselessly dull as her father, Alexis Croucher is too many smiles as the well-meaning but dronelike nursing candidate overseeing the transplant, and Hearn makes AJ so utterly insufferable the character practically becomes an advertisement for alcohol instead of a warning against it.
Director David Epstein has given the show a mostly perfunctory staging that doesnít make sense of Evansís woozy diatribe, but also doesnít mask it from view. Heís willing to present the play, warts and all, though Lipstick on a Pig might have been better served with at least a layer or two of foundation. You canít trick someone into believing something is completely different from what it is, but you can at least accentuate whatever beauty there is to be found.
Lipstick on a Pig