Theatre Review by Matthew Murray - April 17, 2017
Groundhog Day the Musical. Book by Danny Rubin. Music and Lyrics by Tim Minchin. Directed by Matthew Warchus. Choreographed by Peter Darling. Co-Choreographer Ellen Kane. Scenic & costume design by Rob Howell. Music supervision, orchestrations & dance arrangements by Christopher Nightingale. Illusions by Paul Kieve. Lighting design by Hugh Vanstone. Sound design by Simon Baker. Hair & make-up design by Campbell Young Associates. Video design by Andrzej Goulding. Cast: Andy Karl, Barrett Doss, with Rebecca Faulkenberry, John Sanders, Andrew Call, Raymond J. Lee, Heather Ayers, Kevin Bernard, Gerard Canonico, Rheaume Crenshaw, Michael Fatica, Katy Geraghty, Camden Gonzales, Jordan Grubb, Taylor Iman Jones, Tari Kelly, Josh Lamon, Joseph Medeiros, Sean Montgomery, William Parry, Jenna Rubaii, Vishal Vaidya, Travis Waldschmidt, Natalie Wisdom.
Much of this may be attributed to Warchus and his performers, apparently operating on the corrosive and idiotic notion that musical-theatre acting cannot (or shouldn't) be both big and true. More than that, it introduces a major conceptual flaw by making Phil a victim rather than the perpetuator of his own damnation. Who wouldn't hate people as vapid and plasticky as these? Phil rejects them in the movie because he doesn't understand them, giving him a journey to undertake: to realize his own humanity as well as everyone else's. Here, he's an archetype of crisply creased evil doing battle with a townful of stereotype-embodying hicks, so there's no reason to root for his transformation, even if it means succeeding with Rita (Barrett Doss), the closest thing to a satellite of sanity in his orbit.
Even so, their relationship's best moments are temporary oases along the mad dash that is this musical. Providing no time for you (or anyone involved) to breathe, Warchus and Darling load the action with sprawling dance showcases; fancy scenic tricks like a stylized car chase; a magic-tinted death montage (with handsome illusions by Paul Kieve); a rock-concert rave that involves, among other activities, a giant groundhog playing the drums; and more. But all this frenzy occurs for no dramatic or theatrical reason, and it doesn't so much create energy as it does sap it; it's exhausting watching any show try harder than necessary to engage you, all while missing the underlying point.
When he zooms in, however, things get bland quickly. The townsfolk have their requisite dopey beige number, and Phil has his one-dimensional holier-than-thou solo. ("One little store selling plaid shirts and rakes, and it's / Huntin' and fishin' and half-pounder steaks" runs one of its cleverer passages.) His "what's happening?" spot equates small-town doctors with quacks and Scientologists. He sings a throat-shredder called "Hope" that derives its comedy from being about not killing himself while he attempts suicide several dozen times. He approaches thoughtfulness with "Everything About You," where he rattles off Rita's positive qualities, and the two feign connection in the generic "If I Had My Time Again." ("Sometimes / It's like I'm stumbling forward / Hustled forward / Jostled from behind by time.") And it's best not to ask why Ned and one of Phil's discarded conquests, Nancy, each get big solos (the latter the inexplicable Act II opener) despite having no critical importance to the plot.
David Holcenberg's 11-piece band and Christopher Nightingale's orchestrations make them all sound nice enough. And Rob Howell has provided astute visuals for both the always-in-motion sets and costumes, which have been aggressively but not unattractively lighted by Hugh Vanstone. But only Doss lights sparks of actual feeling, hinting at Rita's flesh and blood. Doss plays her down rather than up, keeping a few secrets rather than putting them all on aggravated display, so there's always more to unlock. Her songs are among the score's tritest ("One day, someday, my prince may come," she sings at one point, "But it doesn't seem likely / And even if he came and he liked me / It's likely / He'd be / Not quite / My type"), but no one is more real.
This includes Karl, whose entire characterization of Phil is built on a smarmy smirk and an inflated-chest bravado that may have been right for his far-better turns in On the Twentieth Century and Rocky, but here register as calculated and off-putting. The unquenchable angry tinge in his otherwise precise and piercing singing voice, doesn't help; this Phil comes across not so much as a slumming news personality in need of a wake-up call as a take-no-prisoners hedge-fund manager targeting his next big account.
Karl was transformed after his accident, though, when his natural humility and heart became visible beneath the lacquer for the very first time. That man is one you wouldn't mind hanging out with time and time again. But for Karl's impenetrable Phil and the rest of this inchoate Groundhog Day, once is more than enough.